11 Comments
User's avatar
Jenna Vandenberg's avatar

Stories like your aunt/ dad’s about their mother always make me worry about how I’m messing up my own kids. 😱

May we all have a grandma redemption arc!

Expand full comment
Amanda B. Hinton's avatar

I worry a lot about that, too. The only thing that helps me not stay frozen from fear with my own daughter is that ruptures in relationship will always happen — what counts is the repair. I'm always eager and ready to apologize, offer affection and talk about how I want to do better next time ... whenever I haven't met my own standards, parenting or otherwise. And I do think that will count for something in the years ahead.

Expand full comment
Portia's avatar

It will in the future and it even does now, Amanda.

Expand full comment
Antonia Malchik's avatar

So beautiful, Amanda! I'm in the midst of reading "Women Who Run With the Wolves" for the first time, and so much of what you write here hits the same notes.

Expand full comment
Ben Bon's avatar

Sometimes it is not about who the person was, but what they mean to you.

Expand full comment
Kathy Napoli's avatar

Her story your storytelling both amazing.

Expand full comment
Jeffrey Streeter's avatar

"I keep her picture next to me so that I never forget that we all have layers inside our stories. And no one can ever know the full truth of what we experience." I love the nuance and poise of this beautiful essay, Amanda!

Expand full comment
Donna McArthur's avatar

We are all layered in complexity but most of the time we forget. We look around and take things at surface value and, incorrectly, judge what we see based on that without taking the time or doing the work to go deeper. This is a great call to widen our perspective and open our heart.

Expand full comment
Bhoomika's avatar

I needed/ need to hear this. Today and everyday. 🧡

Expand full comment
Gail Sideman's avatar

First of all, this piece is magnificently written. We all fu** up in life. YOU are your grandmother's redemption, Amanda.

Expand full comment
Sarah Teresa Cook's avatar

This was a lovely read.

Expand full comment